
Roll-a-nativity from 2Teaching Mommies - I laminated the pieces with magnet backing with my Xyron so they would stick to the cookie sheet.
Do-a-dot art from DLTK-kids

Tonging ornaments (or place by hand) into apricot tray
Tweezing beads (these are those beads that you can iron and make stick together to form shapes)
Pouring tiny buttons
Nativity sticker scene
Decorate a tree stickers
Christmas/Winter themed puzzle
Star shaped nesting boxes
Sorting Christmas themed erasers
Grow a candy cane and Christmas tree
Christmas themed pattern blocks from PreKinders
Magnet page with tiny bows from DLTK-kids
Stringing buttons
Weaving ribbons
Open and close containers (inside each box is a sticker or little trinket that goes with the box shape)
Tonging pom poms and putting in a Christmas tree tray
Spooning small jingle bells in bell shaped trays
I got a lot of my items from after-Christmas sales in stores and on Orientaltrading.com and a few items from yard sales.
We also haves several toy nativities that the kids can play with:
This one that I made and these two (L - Melissa and Doug, R- Fisher Price)